Allen Rumsey Supper Club

Reviews about Allen Rumsey Supper Club

• Andrew McDonald

  May, 31 2018
  ★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
  Came with friends to enjoy the patio on a fine summer evening. The local beer with good and the food options were enjoyable too!
• Kimberly Sidwell

  May, 03 2018
  ★ ★ ☆ ☆ ☆
  This restaurant has a genuine old charm to it, while beng exceptionally clean and new. Nicely upholstered booths and chairs, oil lamps at each table, artwork on every wall. The lighting is dim and romantic. The staff was very nice. We had the french fried shrimp and the 9oz filet. All were very good portions and were quality products. Even the bread brought to the table was warm, soft, and was seemingly homemade. Very good experience. We will be back.
  
  Update as of 6.12.17 - returned for dinner for a second time. Found an entirely different staff than the first visit, but to be fair there was only ever one staff member we saw during our first visit.
  The staff are very green, experienced a number of problems during our visit, and generally it was not a great experience. The ambience is still great, but I found the manager to be somewhat awkward in her social skills, our waiter was nice, but probably had too many tables for his experience level, he didn't check in much, my order was brought out incorrectly and I was told by the waiter the kitchen messed up, when the corrected order was brought the kitchen said the waiter messed up and my bill would be adjusted, my bill showed up and the adjustment was not made, I had to wait while that was corrected, in the meantime I was brought out a creme brule to find it had no actual bruled sugar on top, and finally when I asked to have my parking validated at the hostess stand... They stamped my parking ticket, but the valet still charges you for your parking (unlike any other validation I have previously experienced). This place is over priced for what you receive. Overly whipped starchy mashed potatoes, a $48 steak that was not very flavorful, and not much else.
  The highlight of the entire thing, and the reason I offered two stars rather than the 1 everything above would have earned, the Caesar salad made table side. The waitress did a great job, she explained everything very well, she was enjoyable, and frankly that was the best food I had all night. So thank you salad lady, you were the glimmer of hope.

Photos and maps

The nearest companies

• Hutchins Hall

  Establishment, University

  701 South State Street, Ann Arbor, MI 48109

  campusinfo.umich.edu
• Cook William W Legal Research Library

  Establishment, Library

  801 Monroe Street, Ann Arbor, MI 48109

  +1 734-764-9324

  law.umich.edu
• Kirkland and Ellis Cafe

  Establishment, Food, Cafe

  625 South State Street, Ann Arbor, MI 48104

  +1 734-763-9762

  prgmichigan.com

  Open now: Until 08:00pm
• Law Quadrangle

  Establishment, University

  625 South State Street, Ann Arbor, MI 48109

  +1 734-764-0537

  law.umich.edu

  Open now: Open 24 Hours
• Phid House Kent Inn of Phi Delta Phi

  Establishment, University

  University Of Michigan, 502 East Madison Street, Ann Arbor, MI 48104
• W16 Parking Lot

  Establishment, Parking

  Ann Arbor, Ann Arbor, MI 48104